Unit 2, Lesson 1
In Progress

Advanced Argumentation and Fluency

Unit Progress
0% Complete

advanced argumentation and fluency




SESSION 1 (80 min) ANTICIPATION

Part 1 – “The Emphasis Shift”( 15- 20 min)

“The Emphasis Shift”

Instruction: Show three identical sentences on screen. Ask students to read them aloud, stressing only the bold word.

  1. I didn’t say she stole the money. (Someone else said it.)
  2. I didn’t say she stole the money. (I implied it/wrote it.)
  3. I didn’t say she stole the money. (She stole something else.)
  • Discussion: How does moving the stress change the “flow” and meaning?

Part 2: Vocabulary Development (15 min)

The teacher explicitly introduces key vocabulary needed for the lesson, ensuring students clearly understand meaning and use. The words include:

In Favor:

  • To advocate for: To publicly support or suggest a particular way of doing something.
    • “Many experts advocate for a complete shift toward renewable energy.”
  • A compelling argument: A point that is so strong it is difficult to disagree with.
    • “There is a compelling argument to be made for shorter work weeks.”
  • To be in complete accord with: A formal way to say you agree entirely.
    • “I am in complete accord with the previous speaker regarding student autonomy.”
  • To substantiate: To provide evidence to support or prove the truth of something.
    • “The latest data substantiates the claim that immersion is the best way to learn.”

Against (Opposing an Argument)

Use these to highlight nuances in a flawed argument or to show direct opposition.

  • To take issue with: To disagree with or be offended by something.
    • “I must take issue with the suggestion that technology hinders social skills.”
  • A flawed premise: An idea that an argument is based on which is actually incorrect.
    • “The opponent’s argument rests on a flawed premise regarding economic growth.”
  • To refute: To prove a statement or theory to be wrong or false.
    • “Recent studies refute the idea that multitasking increases productivity.”
  • To cast doubt on: To make something seem less certain or reliable.
    • “This evidence casts doubt on the long-term viability of the project.”

The “Middle Ground”

C1 students excel when they can acknowledge the other side before making their own point (this creates excellent cohesion).

  • To concede a point: To admit that something is true or logical, even if you disagree with the main idea.
    • “While I concede the point that costs are high, the benefits outweigh them.”
  • Of paramount importance: Used to emphasize that one specific point is more important than others.
    • “Safety remains of paramount importance in this discussion.”
  • Conversely: Used to introduce a statement that contrasts with or reverses the previous one.
    • “The city is vibrant and full of life; conversely, it can be incredibly lonely.”


Quick game to go over the vocabulary: Bamboozle or Kahoot

Part 3: Grammar Introduction using Presentation (20 min)

Grammar Introduction: Fronting

Theory: Fronting involves moving an adverbial phrase or a prepositional phrase to the beginning of the sentence.

  • Place/Position: In the middle of the valley stood an ancient oak tree.
  • Direction/Movement: Into the room burst the angry manager.
  • Manner/Adverbs: Slowly and silently, the thief opened the window. The “Flow” Rule: We often “front” information that was mentioned in the previous sentence to create a bridge (e.g., “I looked at the shelf. On that shelf was the key.”)

Part 4: Guided Practice (25 min)

Instruction: Give students a “flat” police report. They must rewrite it using Fronting to make it sound like a dramatic mystery novel.

  • Flat: A bloodstained glove lay behind the sofa. —–>Behind the sofa lay a bloodstained glove.
  • Flat: The suspect ran out of the back door. —–>Out of the back door ran the suspect.
  • Flat: He spoke quietly but firmly. ——> Quietly but firmly, he spoke.

“The Great Debate Spotlight” (40 min)

Activity: Persuasive Fronting “Battle”

  • Step 1: The Topic (5 min): Assign a controversial but lighthearted topic (e.g., “Should AI replace teachers?” or “Is social media ruining our attention spans?”). Split the class into “Pro” and “Con.”
  • Step 2: The Rhetorical Prep (15 min): Students must write 3 “power statements” using fronting for emphasis.
    • Instead of: “Our future is at stake here.”
    • Fronted:At stake here is our very future.”
    • Instead of: “The solution lies within our community.”
    • Fronted:Within our community lies the solution.”
  • Step 3: The Mini-Debate (15 min): Students present their arguments. To earn a “Fluency Point,” they must transition smoothly from their partner’s point using a fronted adverbial (e.g., Contrary to that point stands the fact that…”).
  • Step 4: Reflection (5 min): Discuss which version sounded more “authoritative” or “eloquent” (using your unit vocabulary!)

Part 1 – “The Narrative Flow”( 2 x 40min)

Reinforcement:

Creative Task:

  1. Period 1 (The Descriptive Journey): Students write a “Travel Vlog” script or a “Gothic Horror” intro. They must use at least 5 examples of fronting and 4 vocabulary words.
  2. Period 2 (The Flow Circle): Students stand in a circle. One student starts a story with a fronted phrase (e.g., “Beyond the mountains lived a dragon…”). The next student must continue, fronting the next location or action (e.g., “Through the fire flew a bird…”). The goal is non-stop flow for 5 minutes.

NEE – Agregar el tipo de adaptaciones curriculares

Principio II: Pautas 6.1 – 6.3 – 6.4 
Principio III: Pautas 7.1 – 8.1 – 9.1
ALUMNO 1: Constante monitoreo. Dar tiempo adicional para el desarrollo de la actividad y se reduce el número de ejercicios o se modifican los ejercicios con un nivel de dificultad reducido, de acuerdo con sus necesidades académicas. 
ALUMNO 2: Constante monitoreo, Dar tiempo adicional para el desarrollo de la actividad y se reduce el número de ejercicios o se modifican los ejercicios con un nivel de dificultad reducido, de acuerdo con sus necesidades académicas.
ALUMNO 3: Constante monitoreo. Corroborar que el contenido entregado en clase haya sido comprendido por la estudiante mediante retroalimentación.